Investment research report for ACGL

Table of Contents

Executive Summary
Valuation Analysis
Industry and Competitors Analysis
Financial Analysis
Earnings Call Multi-Year Analysis
Financial Statements Multi Year
Insider Trading Analysis
Management Compensation Benchmark Analysis
Proxy Statement Analysis
News Analysis
Technical Indicators Analysis
Financial Statements Annual
Financial Statements Quarterly
Earnings Call Analysis

Executive Summary

Company Overview

Arch Capital Group Ltd. (ACGL) is a Bermuda-based global insurance and reinsurance company. It operates through three segments: Insurance, Reinsurance, and Mortgage. ACGL provides a diverse range of property, casualty, and mortgage insurance products and services worldwide.

Financial Highlights

  • Strong underwriting performance across all segments, with a combined ratio of 79.3% in 2023
  • Net premiums written grew 21.6% to $13.5 billion in 2023, driven by growth across all segments
  • Robust financial position with total assets of $58.9 billion and shareholders’ equity of $18.4 billion as of December 31, 2023
  • Consistent profitability, with net income available to common shareholders of $4.4 billion in 2023

Competitive Advantages

  • Diversified business model mitigates risk and provides earnings stability
  • Disciplined underwriting and prudent risk management strategies
  • Strong balance sheet and financial flexibility to support growth initiatives
  • Effective capital management through share repurchases and strategic acquisitions

Outlook and Growth Strategies

  • Capitalize on favorable market conditions and pricing environment across insurance and reinsurance segments
  • Expand mortgage insurance business through geographic diversification and strategic partnerships
  • Maintain focus on underwriting discipline, risk management, and capital allocation
  • Invest in talent, technology, and operational efficiency to drive long-term growth and profitability

Back to Table of Contents

Valuation Analysis

PE ratio

  • Low: 6.738977193427345
  • Base: 12.479552974501885
  • High: 18.220128755576425

PB ratio

  • Low: 1.0783135858486137
  • Base: 1.364403747840802
  • High: 1.6504939098329903

DPS Growth

  • Low: 0.52%
  • Med: 4.43%
  • High: 7.34%

FCF Growth

  • Low: 12.16%
  • Med: 19.72%
  • High: 24.49%

Value forecast by FCF

  • Low: 503.67
  • Med: 802.43
  • High: 1078.49

Value forecast by DPS

  • Low: 254.10
  • Med: 317.26
  • High: 376.58

The current price for ACGL is $100.8.

Price target for 18 months from now

  • Low: 142.40
  • Med: 173.86
  • High: 202.94

Price target for 4 years from now

  • Low: 211.73
  • Med: 295.61
  • High: 373.18

Price target for 10 years from now

  • Low: 378.13
  • Med: 587.83
  • High: 781.76

The net present value multiplier discounted at 10.22% suggests the value of the stock is:
– Low: 3.75
– Med: 5.83
– High: 7.76

The upside/downside ratio is 28.44, and our rating is Strong Buy.

Back to Table of Contents

Industry and Competitors Analysis

ACGL’s Competitive Positioning

Based on the information provided, ACGL (Arch Capital Group Ltd.) operates in the insurance industry, specifically providing insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage insurance products worldwide. Some key points about ACGL and its competitive positioning:

ACGL operates in the diversified insurance market, offering a range of insurance products across property, casualty, life, and mortgage insurance lines. Its main competitors appear to be other large, diversified insurance companies like AIG, Equitable Holdings, Sun Life Financial, The Hartford, Aegon, Berkshire Hathaway, AXA, etc. These are well-established players in the global insurance market.

In terms of market capitalization, ACGL ($38.5B) is smaller than giants like Berkshire Hathaway ($897B), AIG ($52.3B), AXA ($80.4B) but larger than some like Equitable ($13.5B), Aegon ($11.3B). Its financial metrics like revenue growth, profit margins, and balance sheet strength appear reasonably healthy compared to peers, suggesting a decent competitive positioning.

However, it faces intense competition from the larger, more diversified insurance conglomerates that have bigger scale and resources globally. Maintaining product innovation, risk management, and operational efficiency will be key to sustaining its competitive positioning.

Summary

In summary, ACGL is a sizable player in the highly competitive global insurance market, focused on providing diversified insurance solutions. While not the largest, its financials indicate a solid positioning among peers, though it likely lacks the scale of the biggest insurance giants.

Back to Table of Contents

Chart of Competitors

"Chart of Competitors"

Back to Table of Contents

Financial Analysis

Financial Strength

The company has maintained a relatively low debt-to-equity ratio around 0.15-0.25 over the past few years, indicating a conservative capital structure and financial flexibility. Interest coverage ratios are generally high (above 10x in most quarters), suggesting the company can comfortably service its debt obligations. Return on equity has been volatile but mostly positive, ranging from around 1-12% in recent years.

Potential for Growth

Revenue growth has been uneven, with some quarters showing decent growth (around 10-20%) and others showing declines. The analyst estimates suggest expectations for continued revenue growth over the next few years, averaging around 5-10% annually through 2028. Net income growth has also been volatile but is estimated to grow at a high single-digit to low double-digit rate going forward.

Competitive Advantage

As an insurance and reinsurance provider, the company likely benefits from scale, diversification across product lines, and strong underwriting capabilities as competitive advantages. However, the insurance industry is highly competitive, so sustainable advantages can be difficult to maintain.

Quality of Management

Profitability metrics like return on equity and return on assets suggest reasonably good operational performance by management, though with some volatility. The company has generally maintained a strong balance sheet, which could reflect prudent capital management policies.

Shareholder Friendliness

The company pays a dividend, though the yield is relatively low at around 0.3-0.4%. Share repurchases do not appear to be a major use of capital based on the data provided. Valuation multiples like P/E and P/B ratios have generally been in line with industry averages.

Valuation

Based on analyst estimates, the forward P/E ratio for 2028 is around 10x, which could be considered reasonably valued or slightly undervalued for the insurance industry. However, valuation is highly dependent on future growth assumptions and profitability levels, which can be volatile for insurers.

In summary, ACGL appears to be a financially solid insurance company with decent growth prospects, though growth has been uneven historically. Management seems capable, and the valuation could be attractive if the company can deliver on expected earnings growth. As with any insurer, the company remains exposed to underwriting risks and market cyclicality.

Back to Table of Contents

Chart of Key Per Share Metrics

"Chart of Key Per Share Metrics"

Back to Table of Contents

Chart of Absolute Metrics

"Chart of Absolute Metrics"

Back to Table of Contents

Earnings Call Multi-Year Analysis

Disciplined Underwriting and Cycle Management

Arch Capital has a strong culture of underwriting discipline and actively manages its business across insurance cycles. The company is adept at deploying capital into the most attractive opportunities when market conditions are favorable, while maintaining pricing discipline during softer markets.

Diversified Business Model

Arch’s diversified platform across insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage insurance segments provides earnings stability and allows the company to capitalize on opportunities across different market conditions. This diversification is a key competitive advantage.

Capitalizing on Hard Market Conditions

Arch is currently benefiting from a hardening property and casualty insurance market, with broad-based rate increases exceeding loss cost trends. The company is leveraging its underwriting expertise to grow profitably in this environment, particularly in specialty lines.

Mortgage Insurance Strength

The mortgage insurance segment has consistently delivered excellent underwriting results, benefiting from strong housing market conditions, high credit quality, and prudent risk selection. This segment provides valuable earnings diversification.

Prudent Reserving and Risk Management

Arch takes a conservative approach to reserving, incorporating prudent assumptions for factors like inflation and social inflation. The company actively manages its risk exposures, maintaining a strong balance sheet and financial flexibility.

Proactive Capital Management

Arch actively manages its capital through share repurchases, reinsurance arrangements, and disciplined capital allocation to the most attractive opportunities. The company strikes a balance between investing for growth and returning capital to shareholders.

Investment Portfolio Positioning

Arch has been proactively repositioning its investment portfolio to adapt to the rising interest rate environment, which should drive higher investment income over time.

Overall, Arch Capital’s disciplined underwriting culture, diversified business model, prudent risk management, and active capital allocation position the company well to navigate insurance market cycles and deliver strong long-term returns for investors.

Back to Table of Contents

Financial Statements Multi Year

Strong and Consistent Underwriting Performance

Arch Capital Group Ltd has demonstrated strong and consistent underwriting performance across its insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage segments. This is driven by the company’s disciplined underwriting, prudent risk management, and favorable market conditions.

Diversified Business Model

Arch Capital’s business model is diversified, with a balanced mix of operations across different segments. This provides stability to the company’s earnings and mitigates risks. Arch Capital dynamically allocates capital across its segments based on market opportunities.

Robust Financial Position

Arch Capital maintains a robust financial position, with a strong balance sheet, healthy capital ratios, and ample liquidity. This financial flexibility allows the company to support growth initiatives and withstand potential shocks.

Prudent Capital Management

Arch Capital’s capital management strategy is prudent, involving share repurchases, strategic acquisitions, and ongoing investments in talent and technology to drive operational efficiency.

Solid Investment Performance

Arch Capital’s investment portfolio is well-diversified, focused on high-quality fixed-income securities and alternative investments, generating stable investment income.

Effective Risk Management

Arch Capital’s risk management strategies are effective, including setting limits on catastrophe exposures, utilizing reinsurance programs, and maintaining a well-diversified mortgage insurance portfolio.

Consistent Growth in Key Metrics

Arch Capital has consistently grown its key financial metrics, such as net premiums written, underwriting income, net income, and book value per share, demonstrating the company’s ability to create long-term shareholder value.

Overall, Arch Capital’s financial statements highlight its strong underwriting discipline, diversified business model, robust capitalization, and effective risk management strategies, positioning the company well for sustainable growth and profitability over the long term.

Back to Table of Contents

Insider Trading Analysis

Long-Term Patterns

The CEO (GRANDISSON MARC) and CFO (PETRILLO LOUIS T) have been actively managing their ownership over the long-term, with a mix of stock awards, sales, and gifts. This suggests they are closely aligned with shareholders.

Several other key executives like the President (Papadopoulo Nicolas) and Chief Underwriting Officer (Rajeh Maamoun) have also received substantial stock awards over time, indicating a focus on long-term incentives.

Insider ownership remains high, with the CEO, CFO, and other top executives collectively owning over 1 million shares, suggesting strong alignment with shareholders.

Short-Term Patterns

In the most recent 2 years, there have been a number of stock option exercises and share sales by executives, likely for diversification and liquidity purposes. This is common and not necessarily a concern.

The CEO and CFO have both made some recent gifts of shares to family members, which could be for estate planning purposes.

There have been a few isolated instances of larger-than-normal share sales, but these appear to be one-off events rather than a broader trend.

Implications

The long-term insider ownership and equity incentive patterns suggest the management team is focused on driving long-term shareholder value.

The short-term trading activity is generally in line with typical diversification and liquidity needs, and does not raise major red flags.

Overall, the insider trading activity indicates a management team that is well-aligned with shareholders and focused on the company’s long-term success. This should provide reassurance for both long-term and short-term investors.

Back to Table of Contents

Management Compensation Benchmark Analysis

Executive Compensation Structure at Arch Capital Group Ltd. (ACGL)

Based on the information provided, it appears that the executive compensation for Arch Capital Group Ltd. (ACGL) is structured in a way that aligns with creating long-term shareholder value:

  1. The base salary portion of total compensation for the ACGL executives is relatively low, averaging around 14.3% across all years and executives reported. This suggests that a significant portion of their total compensation is tied to variable, performance-based elements like stock awards and incentive plan compensation.

  2. The CEO, Marc Grandisson, had a base salary portion of around 9-10% of his total compensation in 2022 and 2023, indicating a heavy emphasis on variable pay.

  3. Other key executives like the CFO, François Morin, and the President and Chief Underwriting Officer, Nicolas Papadopoulo, also had base salary portions in the 11-15% range, further demonstrating the focus on performance-based compensation.

  4. Compared to the other companies examined (EQH, AIG, and ORI), ACGL’s executives have a lower base salary portion of total compensation, on average. This suggests that ACGL’s compensation structure is more heavily weighted towards variable, performance-linked pay, which helps align the interests of executives with those of long-term shareholders.

In summary, the executive compensation structure at ACGL appears to be designed to incentivize and reward long-term value creation for shareholders, with a relatively low base salary component and a greater emphasis on variable, performance-based compensation. This is a positive sign for long-term investors in ACGL.

Back to Table of Contents

Proxy Statement Analysis

Pay Mix

Evaluate the balance between fixed pay (base salary) and variable/at-risk pay (annual/long-term incentives). A higher proportion of compensation tied to performance metrics aligned with long-term value creation is preferable.

Performance Metrics

Analyze the specific financial and operational metrics used for annual bonuses and long-term incentive plans. Metrics like growth in book value per share, combined ratio, return on equity, and total shareholder return over multi-year periods are good indicators of alignment with long-term value.

Long-Term Incentive Plan Design

Assess the types of long-term incentives used (e.g. performance shares, stock options, restricted stock) and their vesting schedules. Plans with longer vesting periods and relative performance requirements can better align executives with sustained value growth.

Clawback Policy

Check if the company has a robust clawback policy to recoup incentive compensation in cases of financial restatements or misconduct, promoting accountability.

Stock Ownership Guidelines

Evaluate the company’s stock ownership requirements for executives, as significant equity ownership can align their interests with shareholders.

Peer Group Benchmarking

Review the peer group used for benchmarking pay levels and design practices to ensure it is relevant and aligned with the company’s strategy and value drivers.

An in-depth analysis of these factors can provide insights into whether Arch Capital’s executive compensation structure truly incentivizes and rewards the creation of long-term sustainable value for shareholders.

Back to Table of Contents

News Analysis for Arch Capital Group Ltd

Positive Sentiment

Analysts frequently reiterate Buy/Outperform ratings and highlight ACGL as a top pick in the insurance sector, citing its strong underwriting performance, earnings growth potential, and attractive valuation.

ACGL continues expanding into new business segments like middle-market P&C insurance, which could drive future growth.

The company has been actively repurchasing shares and increasing dividends, reflecting its solid capital position and commitment to enhancing shareholder value.

ACGL is viewed as well-positioned to benefit from improving pricing trends and higher interest rates in the insurance industry.

Potential Concerns

ACGL faces exposure to catastrophe losses from events like hurricanes, which can impact its quarterly earnings in certain periods.

The economic impacts of COVID-19 led to some estimated losses for ACGL in 2020, though the company has navigated the pandemic relatively well overall.

Increased competition and potential pricing pressures in some insurance lines could weigh on future profitability if not managed effectively.

Overall, the sentiment seems largely positive, with analysts highlighting ACGL’s strengths in underwriting, growth prospects from expansions, and shareholder-friendly capital management. Catastrophe exposure remains an inherent risk, but ACGL’s track record and market positioning are viewed favorably for long-term investors. However, investors should continue monitoring the company’s performance and any significant changes in the operating environment.

Back to Table of Contents

Technical Indicators Analysis

Next Week Trading

The recent price action and technical indicators suggest a potential short-term bullish trend. The TEMA (Triple Exponential Moving Average) is above the current price, indicating an upward momentum. The RSI (Relative Strength Index) is in the neutral range, suggesting the stock is not overbought or oversold. These factors point to potential upside in the near-term, making it a favorable setup for a short-term trading opportunity.

Resistance and Support Levels

The 20-day SMA (Simple Moving Average) at around $100.80 and the 50-day SMA at $97.18 could act as key support levels. The stock has been trading above these moving averages, indicating a bullish trend. On the upside, the 200-day SMA at $86.55 could provide a strong resistance level. A breakout above this level could signal a continuation of the long-term uptrend.

Short-Term Investor

The recent technical indicators, such as the rising TEMA and the RSI in the neutral range, suggest a favorable short-term outlook for ACGL. The stock appears to have the potential for further upside in the near future. Short-term investors may consider taking a long position or looking for trading opportunities around the identified support and resistance levels.

Long-Term Investor

For long-term investors, the overall technical picture is positive. The stock is trading above its 20-day, 50-day, and 200-day SMAs, indicating a strong uptrend. The ADX (Average Directional Index) is also above 25, suggesting a well-defined trend. Long-term investors may consider holding or accumulating the stock, as the long-term outlook appears favorable.

In summary, the technical indicators for ACGL suggest a bullish short-term and long-term outlook, with potential upside opportunities for both short-term traders and long-term investors.

Back to Table of Contents

Chart of Valuation History

"Chart of Valuation History"

Back to Table of Contents

Financial Statements Annual

Financial Statements Annual 2024 Q2

Strong financial performance in 2023

Net income available to Arch common shareholders was $4.4 billion, up significantly from $1.4 billion in 2022. Earnings per diluted common share was $11.62, up from $3.80 in 2022. Net premiums written grew 21.6% to $13.5 billion, driven by growth across the insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage segments. The combined ratio improved to 79.3%, compared to 81.6% in 2022, reflecting strong underwriting performance.

Diversified business model

The company operates through three main segments – insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage – providing a balanced mix of business. The insurance segment contributed $5.9 billion in net premiums written, the reinsurance segment contributed $6.6 billion, and the mortgage segment contributed $1.1 billion. The diversification helps mitigate risk and provides stability to the overall financial results.

Solid capital position and financial flexibility

Total assets grew to $58.9 billion as of December 31, 2023, up from $48.0 billion at the end of 2022. Shareholders’ equity available to Arch increased to $18.4 billion, up from $12.9 billion a year earlier. The company maintains a strong capital base, with the ability to support growth opportunities and withstand potential shocks. Arch has access to various credit facilities, including a $425 million secured facility and a $500 million unsecured facility, providing financial flexibility.

Prudent risk management

The company employs various strategies to manage its exposure to catastrophic events and severe economic conditions, including setting limits on probable maximum losses. Arch’s reinsurance program helps mitigate the impact of large losses, with $4.9 billion in premiums ceded in 2023. The company’s mortgage insurance business has a well-diversified portfolio and utilizes reinsurance to manage its risk exposure.

Ongoing investments in talent and technology

Arch continues to invest in its people, with $93 million in share-based compensation expense in 2023. The company is also focused on enhancing its technological capabilities to improve operational efficiency and support its growth initiatives.

Overall, Arch Capital Group Ltd demonstrated strong financial performance, a diversified business model, a solid capital position, prudent risk management, and ongoing investments in its people and technology in 2023, positioning the company well for future growth and success.

Financial Statements Annual 2023 Q2

Geographic Diversification and Loss Exposure

Arch Capital has a globally diversified business, with operations in Bermuda, the United States, Europe, Canada, Australia, and other regions. The company monitors its exposure to catastrophic events and natural disasters across different geographic zones. It seeks to limit its 1-in-250 year net probable maximum loss from a severe catastrophic event in any geographic zone to approximately 25% of its tangible shareholders’ equity. The company’s peak zone catastrophe exposure is a windstorm affecting the Florida Tri-County, the Northeast US, and the Gulf of Mexico. Arch Capital also has significant exposure to losses due to mortgage defaults resulting from severe economic events. It seeks to limit its modeled Realistic Disaster Scenario (RDS) loss from a severe economic event to approximately 25% of its total tangible shareholders’ equity.

Underwriting Performance

Arch Capital’s insurance segment reported an underwriting income of $225 million, with a combined ratio of 95.0%. The reinsurance segment reported an underwriting income of $314 million, with a combined ratio of 92.2%. The mortgage segment reported an underwriting income of $1,257 million, with a combined ratio of 77.0%.

Investment Performance

Arch Capital’s net investment income increased to $497 million in 2022, compared to $389 million in 2021. The company’s net realized gains on investments were $663 million in 2022, compared to $380 million in 2021.

Capital Management

Arch Capital repurchased approximately 12.9 million common shares for an aggregate cost of $586 million in 2022. The company has $1.0 billion of remaining capacity under its share repurchase program. Arch Capital issued $500 million of Series G Non-Cumulative Preferred Shares in 2021, which are redeemable at the company’s option starting in June 2026.

Acquisitions and Investments

Arch Capital completed the acquisition of Westpac Lenders Mortgage Insurance Limited (WLMI) in Australia and the acquisition of the Somerset Bridge Group Limited in the UK during 2021. The company’s investment in Coface SA, a French trade credit insurance company, had a carrying value of $563 million as of December 31, 2022. Arch Capital’s investment in Greysbridge Holdings Ltd, the parent company of Somers Group Holdings Ltd (formerly Watford Holdings Ltd), had a carrying value of $306 million as of December 31, 2022.

Overall, Arch Capital demonstrated strong underwriting performance across its insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage segments, while also generating solid investment returns and actively managing its capital through share repurchases and strategic acquisitions.

Financial Statements Annual 2022 Q2

Strong financial performance

Arch Capital reported net income available to common shareholders of $2.09 billion in 2021, up from $1.36 billion in 2020 and $1.59 billion in 2019. The company’s underwriting income across its insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage segments totaled $1.24 billion in 2021, up from $481 million in 2020 and $1.09 billion in 2019. The company’s combined ratio, a measure of underwriting profitability, improved to 85.2% in 2021 from 94.0% in 2020 and 82.5% in 2019.

Diversified business mix

Arch Capital has a well-diversified business mix across insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage segments, with each contributing meaningfully to the overall results. The insurance segment reported underwriting income of $117 million in 2021, the reinsurance segment reported $170 million, and the mortgage segment reported $953 million.

Prudent capital management

Arch Capital maintained a strong balance sheet, with total shareholders’ equity of $13.55 billion as of December 31, 2021, up from $13.93 billion as of December 31, 2020. The company repurchased $1.23 billion of its common shares in 2021, demonstrating its commitment to efficient capital management. Arch Capital also raised $500 million through the issuance of Series G Preferred Shares in 2021, further strengthening its capital position.

Favorable reserve development

The company reported net favorable prior-year reserve development of $356 million in 2021, compared to $161 million in 2020 and $164 million in 2019, indicating prudent reserving practices.

Investment performance

Arch Capital’s net investment income declined to $389 million in 2021 from $520 million in 2020 and $628 million in 2019, reflecting the low-interest-rate environment. The company’s investment portfolio remained well-diversified, with a focus on high-quality fixed-income securities and alternative investments.

Overall, Arch Capital’s financial statements demonstrate the company’s strong underwriting performance, prudent risk management, and disciplined capital allocation, positioning it well for continued growth and profitability.

Back to Table of Contents

Financial Statements Quarterly

Financial Statements Quarterly 2024 Q2

Strong Underwriting Performance

The insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage segments all reported strong underwriting results, with the reinsurance segment generating $379 million in underwriting income. The insurance segment’s underwriting income was $86 million, reflecting growth in most lines of business due to new business opportunities, increases in existing accounts, and rate changes. The mortgage segment’s underwriting income was $271 million, driven by favorable prior year reserve development and a lower level of Bellemeade premiums ceded.

Solid Investment Performance

Net investment income was $327 million for the quarter, up from $199 million in the prior year period, reflecting higher yields in the financial markets. The company’s total return on investments was 0.80% for the quarter, compared to the benchmark return of 0.83%.

Healthy Balance Sheet and Capital Position

Book value per share increased 5.2% to $49.36 at March 31, 2024, from $46.94 at December 31, 2023. The company’s debt-to-total capital ratio was 12.3%, and the preferred-to-total capital ratio was 3.8%, indicating a strong capital structure. Arch MI US maintained a PMIER sufficiency ratio of 223% at March 31, 2024, well above the regulatory minimum.

Prudent Risk Management

The company’s peak zone catastrophe exposure, measured by the 1-in-250 year return period net probable maximum loss, was $1.7 billion or 9% of tangible shareholders’ equity. The company’s modeled Realistic Disaster Scenario (RDS) loss from a severe economic event was approximately $1.1 billion or 6% of tangible shareholders’ equity.

Overall, the financial statements demonstrate Arch Capital’s ability to generate strong underwriting and investment results, maintain a robust balance sheet, and prudently manage its risk exposures, positioning the company for continued success.

Financial Statements Quarterly 2024 Q1

Strong Underwriting Performance

Arch Capital delivered excellent underwriting results in the 2023 third quarter, with the insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage segments all generating strong underwriting income. The insurance and reinsurance segments benefited from favorable market conditions and relatively light catastrophe losses, while the mortgage segment continued to see favorable reserve development.

Profitable Growth

Arch Capital grew its net premiums written by 26% in the 2023 third quarter compared to the prior year period, driven by new business opportunities, rate increases, and growth in existing accounts across most lines of business. This profitable growth contributed to the strong underwriting results.

Prudent Capital Management

Arch Capital maintained a strong balance sheet, with a debt-to-total capital ratio of 15.2% and preferred-to-total capital ratio of 4.6% at September 30, 2023. The company also has ample liquidity, with $4.1 billion in cash and short-term investments. This financial flexibility supports Arch Capital’s ability to capitalize on attractive underwriting opportunities.

Diversified Business Mix

Arch Capital’s diversified business model, with operations across insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage, helps mitigate risk and provides stability to earnings. The company’s ability to allocate capital dynamically across these segments based on market conditions is a key competitive advantage.

Favorable Reserve Development

Arch Capital reported net favorable prior-year reserve development across all three of its underwriting segments in the 2023 third quarter, reflecting the company’s disciplined reserving practices and prudent risk management.

Strong Investment Performance

Despite the challenging investment environment, Arch Capital generated a pre-tax total investment return of 4.0% in the 2023 third quarter, outperforming its benchmark. The company’s investment portfolio is well-diversified and conservatively positioned, with an average credit quality of A1.

Overall, Arch Capital’s financial results demonstrate the strength and resilience of its diversified business model, disciplined underwriting, and prudent capital management. These factors position the company well to continue delivering long-term value for shareholders.

Financial Statements Quarterly 2023 Q4

Strong Underwriting Performance

Arch Capital’s insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage segments all generated over $100 million in underwriting income in the 2023 second quarter, reflecting the company’s disciplined underwriting approach and ability to capitalize on favorable market conditions.

Profitable Growth

Arch Capital’s book value per share grew 4.8% in the 2023 second quarter, and the company delivered annualized net income and operating returns on average common equity of 19.6% and 21.5% respectively, demonstrating its ability to generate consistent and stable long-term returns.

Prudent Risk Management

Arch Capital’s exposure to property catastrophe risk remains well within its threshold, and the company has a diversified portfolio that provides flexibility to pursue the most attractive returns across lines and geographies. The company also proactively analyzes inflation trends and incorporates them into its pricing and reserving processes.

Strength in Mortgage Segment

Arch Capital’s mortgage segment continues to be a significant contributor to earnings, generating $253 million of underwriting income in the 2023 second quarter. The segment’s disciplined underwriting approach has produced a portfolio with favorable risk characteristics, including higher FICO scores and lower loan-to-value and debt-to-income ratios.

Solid Investment Performance

Arch Capital’s investment portfolio generated a pretax total return of 5.6% in the 2023 second quarter, outperforming its benchmark, reflecting the company’s active management and relatively short duration positioning.

Prudent Capital Management

Arch Capital maintains a strong capital position, with a debt-to-total capital ratio of 15.7% and preferred-to-total capital ratio of 4.8% at June 30, 2023, providing financial flexibility to support its underwriting operations and growth initiatives.

Overall, Arch Capital’s financial statements demonstrate the company’s ability to deliver consistent and profitable growth through disciplined underwriting, prudent risk management, and active capital allocation, positioning it well to create long-term value for shareholders.

Financial Statements Quarterly 2023 Q3

Strong Underwriting and Investment Performance

Arch Capital reported strong underwriting and investment results, with annualized net income return on average common equity of 22.3% and annualized operating return on average common equity of 20.7% for the 2023 first quarter. The insurance and reinsurance segments saw significant premium growth, with net premiums written increasing 19.1% and 51.5% respectively compared to the prior year period. The mortgage segment continued to perform well, generating $243 million of underwriting income in the 2023 first quarter.

Prudent Capital Management

Book value per share increased 8.4% to $35.35 at March 31, 2023, reflecting the strong underwriting and investment results. Arch maintained a relatively short investment portfolio duration of 2.89 years, positioning the portfolio well for the rising interest rate environment. The company’s debt-to-total capital ratio improved to 16.3% at March 31, 2023, down from 17.4% at the end of 2022.

Favorable Market Conditions

The property and casualty insurance and reinsurance markets remained favorable, with Arch taking advantage of the strong pricing environment to grow its business. The mortgage segment continued to benefit from a focus on credit quality, with the U.S. primary mortgage insurance portfolio delinquency rate declining to 1.65% at March 31, 2023.

Disciplined Risk Management

Arch maintained its focus on disciplined risk management, with its modeled peak zone catastrophe exposure and Realistic Disaster Scenario loss estimates remaining within the company’s risk tolerance. The company’s reinsurance recoverables were well-collateralized, with over 94% of the balance due from carriers with an AM Best rating of A or better or collateralized through various arrangements.

Overall, Arch Capital delivered strong financial results in the 2023 first quarter, demonstrating the benefits of its diversified business model, disciplined underwriting, and prudent capital management approach.

Back to Table of Contents

Earnings Call Analysis

Earnings Call Analysis 2024 Q1

Favorable Underwriting Conditions

Arch has been able to capitalize on broadly favorable underwriting conditions in the property and casualty sectors, leading to record financial performance in 2023. The company has been able to deploy capital early in the hard market cycle to fully capitalize on the market opportunity.

Disciplined Underwriting Approach

Arch takes a disciplined approach to underwriting, focusing on rate adequacy regardless of market conditions. This has allowed them to avoid taking on excessive risk during softer market conditions.

Turning Casualty Insurance Market

The casualty insurance market is turning, with insurers being more cautious and adding to their margin of safety. This could lead to profitable underwriting opportunities for Arch over the next several years as the market remediates.

Exceptional Reinsurance Segment

Arch’s reinsurance segment had an exceptional year, with underwriting income nearly doubling from 2022. The company sees continued strong profitability in the reinsurance market.

Valuable Mortgage Insurance Segment

Arch’s mortgage insurance segment remains a valuable source of earnings diversification, with the credit profile of the U.S. primary MI portfolio remaining excellent.

Strong Balance Sheet and Financial Flexibility

Arch maintains a very strong balance sheet and financial flexibility, which allows it to pursue growth opportunities as they arise.

Cautious Approach to M&A

The company is cautious about M&A, focusing on deals that can generate a proper margin of safety and return on capital, while also preserving Arch’s strong corporate culture.

Overall, Arch appears to be well-positioned to capitalize on favorable market conditions across its diversified business segments, while maintaining a disciplined and prudent approach to underwriting and capital allocation.

Earnings Call Analysis 2023 Q4

Arch Capital is well-positioned to capitalize on the current hard insurance market

Arch Capital is well-positioned to capitalize on the current hard insurance market, with strong growth and profitability across its insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage segments. The company expects the hard market to persist into 2024 and 2025.

Reinsurance segment is a key driver of growth

The reinsurance segment is a key driver of growth, with 45% year-over-year premium growth in Q3. Arch expects continued strong property reinsurance market conditions in the 2024 renewal cycle.

Increasing opportunities in casualty reinsurance

The company sees increasing opportunities in casualty reinsurance as the industry grapples with reserve adequacy issues, particularly in larger accounts. Arch is prepared to deploy more capital into this segment as the hard market develops.

Mortgage segment continues to deliver high-quality earnings

The mortgage segment continues to deliver high-quality earnings, though new insurance written has been affected by lower mortgage originations. Arch’s international mortgage business is a growing opportunity.

Disciplined, data-driven approach to underwriting and capital allocation

Arch is maintaining a disciplined, data-driven approach to underwriting and capital allocation, with a focus on maximizing risk-adjusted returns. The company’s underwriters are well-aligned with shareholders through the compensation structure.

While the company is optimistic about the market environment, management is cautious about loss trends, particularly in casualty lines, and is taking a prudent approach to reserving to address potential industry-wide issues.

Overall, Arch Capital appears well-positioned to navigate the current insurance cycle and capitalize on opportunities, while maintaining a focus on risk management and shareholder value creation.

Earnings Call Analysis 2023 Q3

Favorable Insurance Cycle and Market Conditions

Arch is operating in a favorable “sweet spot” of the insurance cycle, with most markets still in the 11 o’clock position on the insurance clock, indicating strong pricing and underwriting conditions. This hard market environment is expected to continue for some time.

The company is benefiting from heightened uncertainty and imbalances in supply and demand for insurance coverage, which is sustaining the hard market. Arch is able to deploy capital and provide capacity to clients in this environment.

Diversified Business Model and Strong Performance

Arch’s diversified business model, with strong performance across its Insurance, Reinsurance, and Mortgage segments, is generating excellent underwriting profitability and risk-adjusted returns. The mortgage business in particular continues to be a valuable source of capital.

Prudent Reserving and Risk Management

Arch is taking a prudent and disciplined approach to reserving, adding a margin of safety to account for uncertainty around loss trends and inflation. This conservative stance is helping sustain the favorable underwriting results.

While Arch’s peak zone exposure has increased, the company remains well within its internal risk tolerance limits. Management indicates there is still room for further growth in property catastrophe exposure as market conditions warrant.

Focus on Organic Growth

The company is focused on organic growth opportunities rather than M&A at this time, given the attractive market conditions and ability to deploy capital effectively within the existing platform.

Overall, Arch appears to be executing well and positioning itself to capitalize on the extended hard market environment, while maintaining a prudent and disciplined approach to risk management. The long-term investor should closely monitor the company’s ability to sustain its strong underwriting profitability and book value growth.

Earnings Call Analysis 2023 Q2

Excellent Market Conditions and Opportunities

Arch is seeing excellent market conditions and opportunities, particularly in property and casualty reinsurance. The company is able to grow premiums significantly (35% year-over-year) by being an “underwriting cycle manager” and deploying capital aggressively when market conditions are favorable.

Prudent and Disciplined Approach to Reserving

Arch takes a prudent and disciplined approach to reserving, aiming to book reserves at a 60th percentile confidence level rather than just the average. This helps provide stability and visibility in their results over the long-term.

Mortgage Insurance Segment Performance

The mortgage insurance segment continues to perform well, with a focus on credit quality and data-driven risk selection. Arch sees the mortgage industry maintaining pricing discipline.

Confidence in Rate Adequacy and Risk-Adjusted Returns

Arch is confident in the rate adequacy and risk-adjusted returns of the business they are writing, despite some noise in quarterly results. They have a rigorous process of vetting assumptions and projections at multiple levels.

Gaining Market Share through Relationships and Reputation

Arch’s long-standing relationships and reputation as a reliable market participant have allowed them to gain share, especially in dislocated markets where others have pulled back. Their E&S focus is also a tailwind.

Positive Outlook for Underwriting Results

The company sees further rate improvement and favorable terms and conditions ahead, particularly in property catastrophe reinsurance, which could persist for 2-3 years. This provides a positive outlook for their underwriting results.

Overall, Arch appears to be executing well on its disciplined underwriting-focused strategy, which has positioned it to capitalize on the current hard market environment. The company’s prudent reserving and risk management practices provide confidence in the sustainability of its results.

Earnings Call Analysis 2023 Q1

Underwriting Cycle Management

Arch has a strong culture of underwriting discipline and cycle management. They are currently in Stage 2 of the underwriting cycle, with opportunities for profitable growth as the market hardens.

Diversified Specialty Portfolio

Arch’s breadth of capabilities across many specialty insurance lines enhances its cycle management capabilities and allows it to capitalize on opportunities across different market conditions.

Reinsurance Growth

Arch was well-positioned to capitalize on broad market opportunities and dislocations in the reinsurance segment, leading to exceptional premium growth. This growth is expected to continue, especially in property catastrophe reinsurance.

Insurance Segment Strength

Arch’s insurance segment continues to benefit from hard market conditions, with rate increases generally exceeding loss cost trends. The team is leaning into the hardening market to drive profitable growth.

Mortgage Segment Resilience

The mortgage segment delivered strong underwriting income, benefiting from favorable reserve development as delinquencies declined. The industry is acting in a disciplined and responsible manner amid economic uncertainties.

Investment Income Tailwinds

Arch is well-positioned to benefit from higher reinvestment rates and growth in invested assets, which should fuel increasing net investment income to support the bottom line.

Prudent Risk Management

Arch’s natural catastrophe PML remains well below internal limits, and the company is thoughtfully allocating capital to the most profitable opportunities.

Overall, Arch’s diversified business model, underwriting discipline, and cycle management capabilities position the company well to navigate the current market environment and deliver strong long-term returns for investors.

Earnings Call Analysis 2022 Q4

Arch is a Diversified, Time-Tested Active Capital Allocator

Arch is a diversified, time-tested active capital allocator that focuses on navigating market cycles effectively. The company believes the current environment presents opportunities as the property catastrophe market hardens.

Strong Performance Across Insurance and Reinsurance Segments

Arch’s insurance and reinsurance segments continue to see strong premium growth and solid underwriting performance, with current accident year ex-cat combined ratios of 89.5% and 85.5% respectively. The company sees good opportunities for further growth in 2023.

Excellent Underwriting Results in Mortgage Segment

The mortgage segment continues to deliver excellent underwriting results, with a combined ratio ex-prior year development of 39.9%. Persistency has increased due to rising mortgage rates.

Prudent Investment Portfolio Management

Arch is cautious about its investment portfolio duration and credit/equity risk, which has helped minimize the impact of rising interest rates and weak equity markets on its book value. The company expects investment income to improve as new money yields rise.

Strong and Conservative Balance Sheet

Arch has a strong and conservative balance sheet, with low leverage, which provides flexibility and optionality to take advantage of improving market conditions. The company is focused on maintaining a solid capital position.

Optimistic Outlook and Disciplined Capital Allocation

Arch is optimistic about the opportunities ahead, particularly in the property catastrophe reinsurance market, where it believes it can deploy more capital as the market hardens. The company will be disciplined in allocating capital to the business segments with the best risk-adjusted returns.

Overall, Arch appears well-positioned to capitalize on the hardening market environment, leveraging its diversified platform, underwriting expertise, and strong balance sheet. The company’s focus on cycle management and prudent capital allocation are key strengths for long-term investors.

Earnings Call Analysis 2022 Q3

Arch sees continued rate hardening across many P&C lines, with rates meaningfully above loss cost trends for the past 2-3 annual renewals. Arch believes this attractive level of expected returns should remain in place for the next few years, as perceived risk in the market has increased due to uncertainty around inflation, social inflation, and geopolitical risks.

Investment Portfolio

Arch has been actively repositioning its investment portfolio to shorter durations and higher-yielding securities to adapt to the rising interest rate environment. New money yields on corporate bonds are approaching 4.5%, compared to an embedded book yield of 2.2% at the end of the quarter. Arch expects a meaningful portion of its portfolio to turn over in the next 12 months, allowing it to reinvest at higher yields.

Mortgage Insurance

Arch is comfortable with the credit quality of its mortgage insurance portfolio, as borrower credit profiles have improved during the pandemic. While mortgage origination volumes may slow due to higher interest rates, Arch’s existing in-force book and growing credit risk transfer (CRT) portfolio should provide stability to the top line. Arch remains focused on credit quality and profitability, rather than volume, in its mortgage business.

Reserving and Inflation

Arch has taken a long-term view on loss cost trends, pricing business with higher assumptions even during periods of low inflation. This has allowed Arch to build a reserve buffer that can help absorb the impact of higher-than-expected inflation, without the need for significant reserve charges. Arch manages inflation impact by business segment, seeing it as a net benefit for its mortgage insurance portfolio.

Capital Management

Arch has been actively repurchasing shares, but may need to moderate the pace of buybacks to ensure it has sufficient capital to deploy into the growing P&C and reinsurance opportunities. Arch’s risk management approach, with a focus on diversification and specialty lines, has positioned it well to capitalize on the current market environment.

Overall, Arch appears well-positioned to navigate the current inflationary and rising interest rate environment, with a focus on disciplined underwriting, prudent reserving, and active capital management. The company’s diversified business model and long-term approach to pricing and reserving are key strengths for a long-term investor.

Earnings Call Analysis 2022 Q2

Diversified platform and cycle management strategy

Arch has demonstrated the effectiveness of its diversified platform and ability to actively allocate capital to the most attractive sectors of its business. This has enabled strong underwriting performance across its P&C, Reinsurance, and Mortgage Insurance segments.

Favorable market conditions in P&C

The P&C industry is in a growth phase of the underwriting cycle, with Arch continuing to benefit from rate increases and disciplined underwriting. Specialty lines in particular are seeing very good underwriting conditions.

Resilient Mortgage Insurance business

The Mortgage Insurance segment has continued to deliver excellent underwriting results, benefiting from strong housing demand and credit quality. Rising mortgage rates have reduced refinancing activity, but Arch expects this to improve persistency and returns on the in-force portfolio.

Proactive inflation management

Arch is focused on proactively incorporating new data into its reserving and pricing to help mitigate the impact of inflation. In Mortgage Insurance, rising home prices are also seen as a positive, increasing homeowner equity and reducing potential losses.

Prudent capital management

Arch has repurchased a significant amount of shares, demonstrating confidence in its long-term prospects. The company remains disciplined in its capital allocation, willing to deploy capital to the most attractive opportunities, whether that be organic growth, M&A, or share buybacks.

Cautious on property catastrophe risk

While property catastrophe rates have improved, Arch has remained disciplined and not allocated material additional capital to this line, viewing other lines as having better risk-adjusted returns.

Overall, Arch’s diversified business model, cycle management expertise, and prudent risk management suggest it is well-positioned to navigate the current uncertain environment and continue delivering long-term value for shareholders.

Earnings Call Analysis 2022 Q1

Arch Capital Group is well-positioned to capitalize on the current favorable pricing environment in the P&C insurance and reinsurance markets. The company has maintained a disciplined, defensive underwriting approach during softer market conditions, which is now allowing it to grow faster than peers.

The mortgage segment continues to deliver excellent underwriting results, benefiting from strong housing market conditions and high-quality originations. However, the company is focused on maintaining stable returns rather than chasing top-line growth.

Arch’s diversified business model, with a balance between underwriting income and investment income, is seen as a strength that improves the risk-adjusted returns for shareholders.

The company is cautious about being too aggressive with share repurchases at current valuation levels, preferring to deploy capital into the business where it sees the best opportunities. A dividend is not off the table but is not a priority at the moment.

Arch is closely monitoring the potential impact of the proposed changes to the S&P capital model, which could have implications for the mortgage insurance business. The company believes its diversified model provides advantages compared to more focused mortgage insurers.

The company sees the current pricing environment in insurance and reinsurance as favorable, with no signs of competitors taking overly aggressive stances. Arch believes the market remains disciplined, given the various risks and uncertainties it faces.

Overall, Arch appears to be taking a prudent, long-term approach to capital allocation and underwriting, which has served it well through various market cycles. The company’s diversified model and focus on specialty lines are viewed as key competitive advantages.

Earnings Call Analysis 2021 Q4

Diversified platform and underwriting strength

Arch’s diversified business model across insurance, reinsurance, and mortgage insurance provides opportunities to deploy capital and generate expected mid-teens returns on equity.

Hardening P&C market

The P&C market is hardening, with Arch seeing broad-based rate increases across most sectors. This is expected to provide sustainable improved economics for the industry.

Mortgage segment strength

Arch’s mortgage insurance segment continues to deliver exceptional returns, with delinquencies declining to pre-pandemic levels and most loans in forbearance having significant equity protection.

Capital management

Arch actively manages capital, using reinsurance to optimize its capital structure and enable reallocation towards faster growing specialty P&C lines while enhancing the mortgage segment’s return profile.

Cautious reserving approach

Arch is taking a prudent, conservative approach to reserving for COVID-19 related claims, particularly in the mortgage segment, given the ongoing uncertainties around the pandemic’s impact.

Selective growth

Arch is selectively growing in areas where it sees the most attractive risk-adjusted returns, while being judicious in deploying capital to property catastrophe risks.

Overall, Arch’s diversified platform, disciplined underwriting, and proactive capital management position it well to navigate the current market environment and generate strong long-term returns for investors.

Earnings Call Analysis 2021 Q3

Pricing Environment

Arch is seeing strong pricing momentum across its insurance and reinsurance segments, with rate increases comfortably exceeding loss cost trends. The insurance segment saw 43% premium growth, with 30% of that from rate increases. The reinsurance segment also saw strong growth of 64%, benefiting from quota share arrangements as clients seek more capacity. Arch expects the pricing environment to remain favorable for some time, as the industry recognizes the need for higher rates to address various uncertainties like inflation and social inflation.

Inflation Management

Arch is closely monitoring inflation on a line-by-line basis and adjusting pricing and reserving accordingly. In some lines like workers’ comp, inflation is low (0-1%), while in others like excess liability, it is estimated at 8-12%. Arch takes a prudent approach, typically erring on the side of higher inflation assumptions to build in a margin of safety.

Mortgage Insurance Performance

The mortgage insurance segment continues to perform well, generating $250 million in operating earnings. Delinquency rates are declining, and Arch expects a large portion of delinquencies to cure given the strong equity position of borrowers. Arch is expanding its mortgage insurance footprint, including the acquisition of Westpac’s LMI business in Australia.

Capital Management

Arch has ample capital to support growth, and it is actively managing capital, including through share repurchases. The company repurchased $306 million of shares in Q2, representing 45% of year-to-date net income. Arch is open to being more active with share buybacks, even during the wind season, given its diversified business model.

Watford Acquisition

Arch has completed the acquisition of Watford and plans to integrate it more closely with Arch Re, aligning its business model more closely with Arch’s. This could potentially open up opportunities to leverage Watford’s platform, including for Arch’s mortgage insurance business.

Overall, Arch appears well-positioned to capitalize on the favorable market conditions, with a diversified platform, disciplined underwriting, and prudent capital management. The company’s focus on pricing adequacy and inflation management suggests a conservative approach that could benefit long-term investors.

Back to Table of Contents

The information provided on this blog is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as financial advice. You should consult with a qualified financial professional before making any investment decisions. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal.